Quantcast
Latest Stories

No Wikipedia? What if the Internet went down?

By:

WASHINGTON — If a day without Wikipedia was a bother, think bigger. In this plugged-in world, we would barely be able to cope if the entire Internet went down in a city, state or country for a day or a week.

Sure, we’d survive. People have done it. Countries have, as Egypt did last year during the anti-government protests. And most of civilization went along until the 1990s without the Internet. But now we’re so intertwined socially, financially and industrially that suddenly going back to the 1980s would hit the world as hard as a natural disaster, experts say.

No email, Twitter or Facebook. No buying online. No stock trades. No just-in-time industrial shipping. No real-time tracking of diseases. It’s gotten so that not just the entire Internet but individual websites such as Google are considered critical infrastructure, experts said.

“Nobody would die, but there would be a major hassle,” said computer security expert Mikko Hypponen, chief research officer at F-Secure in Helsinki, Finland.

If an Internet outage lasted more than a day or two, the financial hit would be huge, with mass unemployment, said Ken Mayland, a former chief bank economist and president of ClearView Economics. Eugene Spafford, director of Purdue University’s Center for Education and Research in Information Assurance and Security, worries about bank runs and general panic.

Psychologically, too, it could be wrenching.

“I think it’s easier to get off heroin,” said Lisa Welter of New York City, who weaned herself for a month last year from just the social aspects of the Internet — she still paid bills online — and felt as if she was “living in a cave.”

“There would be a sense of loss: What would I do with my time?” said Kimberly Young, a psychologist who directs the Center for Internet Addiction and Recovery.

On Wednesday, certain websites, most prominently Wikipedia, went dark to protest legislation in Congress that would crack down on pirated movies and TV shows. It was a one-day stunt. But it raises questions about our connectedness.

It is possible that hackers, terrorists, accidents or even sunspots could take down the Internet and cause areas to become cut off and unreachable, said Spafford, one of the foremost experts on computer security. The U.S. and other developed nations have multiple and robust routing systems that make it unlikely large areas would be affected, but smaller countries could be vulnerable to nationwide outages, Hypponen said.

The world only has to look back one year to Egypt to see what a sudden unplugging could spawn.

The government of Hosni Mubarak tried to stop protests in January 2011 by switching off the Internet. The shutdown halted businesses, banking operations and — at the height of the demonstrations — the ability of the protest leaders to organize and communicate with one another.

During the five days that the Internet was out, anti-Mubarak activists had to rely on help from abroad to spread their news and update Web pages. The outage harmed protesters’ ability to organize or to counter government propaganda that portrayed them as agents of foreign powers, said Ahmed Saleh, who was in charge of managing the Facebook page that was credited with mobilizing thousands of Egyptians to take to the streets.

With the shutdown, the protests swelled as people unable to follow minute-by-minute what was going on took to the streets.

“No Internet meant that more people went down and realized that this was for real. The protests grew, and so did the anger against the government domestically and internationally,” Saleh said.

He said the lack of Internet also allowed him to “live the moment” because he was not distracted with tweeting and posting on Facebook or analyzing the situation. This, he said, strengthened real face-to-face connections between people.

Nicholas Christin, associate director of the Information Networking Institute at Carnegie Mellon University, said that while a prolonged Internet outage would be uncomfortable, it might also bring out the best in people.

“I think you would find that people are very resilient,” he said. “We would go back to the libraries.”

Christin said he has gone a week without the Internet as part of a vacation. The first few days were rough, he said, but then “it was fantastic.”

Christin did it by choice. Others had it imposed on them because of weather disasters or financial problems. They weren’t nostalgic about it.

For three days, Jill Williams lost the Internet and power because of a California windstorm last month. Her small business requires her to use email to plan events.

“Those three days I felt deprived,” she recalled in an email, responding to a Twitter request for anecdotes about going Internet-less. “The Internet has totally consumed my life, both business as well as pleasure.”

Wyatt McMahon of the Virginia Bioinformatics Institute at Virginia Tech University was having a hard time Wednesday just dealing with the shutdown at Wikipedia, which he leans on as a first step in his searches in his field, which combines statistics and biology.

If the entire Internet were lost, “that would be beyond catastrophic. Every single day, every single hour, if not every 30 minutes, I am using the Internet for work,” McMahon said. “So if anything like that were to happen, it would bring everything to a screeching halt.”

___

Sarah El Deeb in Cairo and Jocelyn Noveck in New York contributed to this report.


Related Stories:


Recent Stories:

Reports: HP poised to eliminate up to 30,000 jobs 18 mins elapsed Health workers buck promotion of 2 ‘tormentors’ 30 mins elapsed US defends visa granted to Raul Castro’s daughter 37 mins elapsed PH still on US ‘watch list’ for counterfeit goods 40 mins elapsed Pacquiao KOs anti-gay allegations 53 mins elapsed Facebook prices IPO at $38 per share 60 mins elapsed US envoy to Israel: US ready to strike Iran 1 hour elapsed Lawyer, client shot dead in Bulacan 1 hour elapsed
Complete stories on our Digital Edition newsstand for tablets, netbooks and mobile phones; 14-issue free trial. About to step out? Get breaking alerts on your mobile.phone. Text ON INQ BREAKING to 4467, for Globe, Smart and Sun subscribers in the Philippines.

Tags: Facebook shutdown , Google Inc. , Google.com , Internet , online business , Twitter-less world , Wikipedia , Yahoo Inc.

Disclaimer: The comments uploaded on this site do not necessarily represent or reflect the views of management and owner of INQUIRER.net. We reserve the right to exclude comments that we deem to be inconsistent with our editorial standards.
  • http://twitter.com/chly2rees chly

    NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

  • http://joboni96.myopenid.com/ joboni96

    there’s an offline version of wikipedia
    you can load on your hardisk
    there’s also google cache

    we can always return to
    1. cellphones
    2. landlines or pots
    3. snail mail
    4. just plain old face2face, without the book

  • http://jaoromero.wordpress.com Jao Romero

    “It is possible that hackers, terrorists, accidents or even sunspots could take down the Internet and cause areas to become cut off and unreachable, said Spafford, one of the foremost experts on computer security. ”
    It is possible, but out of those you listed, hackers would be the most improbable among the bunch. Not only would hackers not take down the internet, but they would actively work to ensure the internet never goes down. hackers take down specific websites, not the entire web. you’d be a stupid hacker if you took down the source of your power.

    i mean, really now. a little thinking would serve you well.

  • Guest

    ATMs would not function and will, of course, have a big impact on Henry Sy’s statement of account, for example. Nobody can really imagine the impact of the worldwide shutdown of the internet since that scenario is without any precedent. Significant parts of financial transactions are done through internet.



Copyright 2011 . All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.
To subscribe to the Philippine Daily Inquirer newspaper in the Philippines, call +63 2 896-6000 for Metro Manila and Metro Cebu or email your subscription request here.
Factual errors? Contact the Philippine Daily Inquirer's day desk. Believe this article violates journalistic ethics? Contact the Inquirer's Reader's Advocate. Or write The Readers' Advocate:
c/o Philippine Daily Inquirer Chino Roces Avenue corner Yague and Mascardo Streets, Makati City, Metro Manila, Philippines Or fax nos. +63 2 8974793 to 94
Advertisement
  1. Joey De Venecia sues NTC, telcos
  2. As Facebook grows, millions say, ‘no, thanks’
  3. Companies ask: Does advertising on Facebook pay?
  4. Google strives to enlighten with new search tool
  5. Facebook co-founder Saverin to stay in Singapore
  6. Guess who won online poll on Naia brawlers
  7. Zuckerberg’s Facebook story is study in contrasts
  8. Filipino hackers fight back, deface Chinese sites
  9. Asia software piracy cost $21B in lost sales
  10. Asia helps drive Facebook’s 1-billion goal
  1. Guess who won online poll on Naia brawlers
  2. Chinese flag ‘flown’, anthem played on Philippine college website
  3. Hackers of ‘unknown origin’ continue cyberwar over Panatag
  4. Filipino hackers fight back, deface Chinese sites
  5. Ousted Yahoo! CEO has cancer— report
  6. Can’t go to a Tesda training center? You can log on wherever you are
  7. Report: Yahoo CEO to step down amid resumé miscue
  8. Robot created by PH students to detect unsafe meat wins 3rd prize in US expo
  9. Joey De Venecia sues NTC, telcos
  10. Facebook CEO turns 28: Does age matter?
  1. Filipino hackers fight back, deface Chinese sites
  2. Hundreds of thousands may lose Internet in July
  3. UP site hacked over Scarborough Shoal
  4. Guess who won online poll on Naia brawlers
  5. No Steve Jobs they, but this team got Filipinos on Internet
  6. Samsung reveals new flagship Galaxy smartphone
  7. Facebook billionaire shuns luxury for startup life
  8. Yahoo CEO apologizes for bogus college degree but won’t resign
  9. Sony’s new Xperia Series smartphones let us connect to TV, tablets, laptops
  10. Chinese flag ‘flown’, anthem played on Philippine college website

News

  • Health workers buck promotion of 2 ‘tormentors’
  • US defends visa granted to Raul Castro’s daughter
  • US envoy to Israel: US ready to strike Iran
  • Lawyer, client shot dead in Bulacan
  • 3 wounded as ‘cop’ goes on shooting spree in Quezon City
  • Sports

  • Pacquiao KOs anti-gay allegations
  • Fiery Lady Eagles stay on top, trip Lady Stags
  • Young Alcala topples 19-under champ Clarito
  • Big Chill ties Cebuana for 2nd
  • Loyola Meralco debuts in S-League
  • Lifestyle

  • ‘Ring of Fire’ eclipse visible from eastern Asia to Texas
  • Fashionistas snap up Kate Middleton’s Jimmy Choos
  • Tattoo removal and hair transplant
  • Fashion retail giant now has its own exclusive credit card
  • Let there be light (underarms)
  • Entertainment

  • A passage to Tawi-Tawi
  • A film that took years to write in Cinemalaya
  • ‘Manoy’ for all seasons
  • Tony DeZuñiga, comic book legend
  • ‘Captive’ preem at Shang’s French fest
  • Business

  • Facebook prices IPO at $38 per share
  • ‘Hot money’ flow slows to a trickle
  • Asian markets mixed but Greek fears weigh
  • BoI makes pitch for 200 projects worth P60B
  • Philippines urged to implement REIT system
  • Technology

  • Reports: HP poised to eliminate up to 30,000 jobs
  • PH still on US ‘watch list’ for counterfeit goods
  • As Facebook grows, millions say, ‘no, thanks’
  • Joey De Venecia sues NTC, telcos
  • Companies ask: Does advertising on Facebook pay?
  • Opinion

  • Editorial cartoon, May 18, 2012
  • It’s not about you
  • Extraordinary gang-up
  • Living in a golden age
  • 15 years
  • Global Nation

  • Japan eyes maritime aid for Philippine defense
  • Philippines willing to share Spratlys bounty – Aquino
  • It’s final: DFA to close 10 foreign posts
  • Aquino to visit US, London next month
  • Philippine-China tensions likely to have modest effects on economy
  • Marketplace
    Advertisement
    © Copyright 1997-2011 INQUIRER.net | All Rights Reserved