Quantcast
Latest Stories

Liking, sharing on Facebook not libelous–Angara

By

Angara said libel in the cybercrime law was not something new. “We are just importing the law of libel for print and broadcast into the Internet. Otherwise there would be a zone of impunity. I can begin attacking maliciously the people I hate,” he added. INQUIRER FILE PHOTO

MANILA, Philippines — Liking and sharing a libelous comment in social networking sites like Facebook will not make the “liker” or “sharer” liable under the cybercrime law so long as he or she does not conspire to commit the crime, Senator Edgardo Angara said on Thursday.

Angara was initially unaware of the terms “like” and “sharing” when reporters asked during a regular forum in the Senate asked whether the act of liking or sharing a malicious comment or remark on Facebook was punishable under the law.

“Anong mag-like? (What’s to like?)” he asked.

After a reporter explained and showed him how to do it on Facebook, Angara said, “No. Not really. You see, the anxiety and apprehension over this are so exaggerated….”

“Hindi. Hindi naman ikaw ang author nito (No. You are not the author (of that libelous comment),” he said when pressed. ‘

“Hindi, audience lang naman sya e. Kapag sinabi kong uy gusto ko yung sinabing yun. Conspirator na ako? Hindi. Audience lang ako. (He is just an audience. If I say, I like what he said. Does that make m conspirator. No. I’m just an audience) We are a non-party. Non Participant,” the senator said.

Even sharing a libelous comment on Facebook, Angara said, was not punishable under the law unless the “sharer” had conspired with the author.

“Kung may connivance. Kung may conspiracy (If there is connivance. If there is conspiracy),” he said.

“Kung ikaw kasabwat, conspirator ka, kilala mo yung nagpadala niyan at nagkausap kayo, ito pag pinadala ko sayo, i-share mo sa lahat, e di conspirator ka (If you are a conspirator, you know the author and he told you to share it to everyone, then you become a conspirator),” he pointed out.

Angara called on the public to calm down, saying the law is not a threat to anyone’s freedom right now.

“I think the first call of the  media, a very powerful conveyor of information, is to calm down and say there’s no threat to anyone’s freedom right now. What we are just saying is that we are apprehensive, we are anxious that it will violate our rights. Nothing so far has been violated,” he said.

“In the first place, the law is not even enforced yet. There’s still no IRR (implementing rules and regulations) e…So there’s no actual injury to anyone and therefore I would appeal very strongly and almost passionately…don’t be afraid. Don’t panic…,” the senator added.

Follow us on Facebook Follow on Twitter Follow on Twitter




Recent Stories:

Japanese, 80, is oldest to scale Everest 32 mins elapsed NP backs Drilon, joins new Senate majority 2 hours elapsed No poll fraud, says Brillantes 2 hours elapsed Lady Bulldogs’ poor reception key in V-League finals game one downfall, says coach 2 hours elapsed 2 men with gunshot wounds found dead in Batangas 2 hours elapsed Tokyo plunges more than 7% as Asian markets fall 2 hours elapsed ‘You people will never be safe’—London attacker 3 hours elapsed Graphic gay sex stirs controversy at Cannes 3 hours elapsed
Complete stories on our Digital Edition newsstand for tablets, netbooks and mobile phones; 14-issue free trial. About to step out? Get breaking alerts on your mobile.phone. Text ON INQ BREAKING to 4467, for Globe, Smart and Sun subscribers in the Philippines.

Tags: Cybercrime law , Facebook , infotech , IT , Libel , Social Media

  • RobertoMagtuytoy

    LET me quote you , zkenpachi.  …” mwalang glang lng po sir… kng hndi k ntatakot s btas nto’y bbgyan kita ng isang sitwasyon… pano kng n-hack ung account mo s facebook at gmiton yun pra siraan ang ibang tao at kakasuhan k ng libel at mgmmulta kng ng npklaking hlaga at mkkulong k ng mhigit 12 n taon, so ok lng sau ng ganun?”…Sagot ko:   Sa kwento mo agad-agad ka naman na makukulong…..Sa Bansa mo ba walang DUE Process?…sa Pilipinas meron.  Papatunayan muna sa HUSGADO ang akusasyon, pag may kasalanan ka , KULONG KA.  Sa kasong LIBEL pero na HACKED pala ang account mo..mas madaling mapatunayan na HACKED nga yung account dahil sa LOG FILE na kasama sa account mo. Therefore, innocente ka!  

    • zkenpachi

      Sa Bansa mo ba walang DUE Process? hmmmm mkhang wla kng alam s ngyayari dito s pinas ah…

      • RobertoMagtuytoy

        Ang alam ko sa PINAS.  Gumaganda na ang Economiya.  Lumalago ang mga kalakaran ng ibat’ibang sector ng lipunan.  Tumataas ang krimen ng HOLDAPAN at ito ay dahil sa marami nang kwarta ang taong bayan na ho-holdapin.

        Noong araw, mga 20 years ago naging Holdaper din ako, mahina ang kita dahil konti lang pera ng tao.  Ngayon, naku daming pera ng taongbayan. Mas maunlad na ang Pilipinas ngayon kumpara mo 20-30 years ago.

  • RobertoMagtuytoy

    To zkenpachi……Yun nga ang depensa mo.  Sa preliminary investigation pa lamang, mapapatunayan na na- hacked ang account mo.  Di na kayo darating sa Korte.Alam mo ba yung KWENTO tunkol kay BOY KUTO?

    • zkenpachi

      mkhang and dami mong alam ah…. IT expert? ahahaha ba’t di k mgsuggest s NBI kng pano mttrace ung mga 20 hackers (report nila khapon)…

      • RobertoMagtuytoy

        Nag suggest na ako…kaya nga HULI na sila…at may katapat na silang BATAS na nilabag…….salamat sa RA10175.

      • zkenpachi

        “kaya nga HULI na sila” ahahaha komedyante k pla… aber bgyan mo daw ako ng link ng news n may nhuli n clang  hacker… alam mo bang hndi mdali ang pgtrace ng IP at may paraan kng pano ito mging secure…

      • RobertoMagtuytoy

        Sampol…Tracert Command.

        Launch a Command Prompt by selecting the Windows Start menu. From “All Programs”, go to “Accessories”, then select “Command Prompt”. It is in the command prompt that tracert is run. Type tracert followed by a space and then type the domain name. Hit “Enter” to launch the trace. 

        GAWA lang ng tao ang internet. 

      • zkenpachi

        cge sampolan mo daw kng may mkita kng hacker jan s cnabi mo… kng gnyan lng kdali ung cnabi mo e mrami n snang nhuli, ngmmarunong k lng pla eh…

      • RobertoMagtuytoy

        hehehhe…babaw mo!

      • zkenpachi

        yan lng ang argumento mo? kala ko ba ngsuggest kna kng pno mhuhuli ung mga hacker… yangon humihingi ako ng sample s paraan mo kng may mttrace k n hacker tapos ssabihin mo lng “hehehe …babaw mo!”

      • RobertoMagtuytoy

        Alam mo Boy KUTO…”Ang kabuuan ay nalalaman sa pamamagitan ng dalawang pandiwa.”….AyON yan kay TATA LINO.

      • zkenpachi

        imbes n sgutin mo ung tanong ko eh nlilihis mo… ang dami kong tanong s taas tapos iba issagot mo… kaloka k dai…

      • zkenpachi

        may paraan pra mhide mo ang IP… sample vpn, Proxy Servers, Hide IP software… tsaka ang galing ng pgcocopy & paste mo ha (Traceroute Tutorial)

  • tarikan

    “Anong mag-like?” You are a very good lawyer but it seems you are facebook ignorant. You could have studied your homework senator before facing the media. I think someone has to provoke some senators/congressmen to just know how potent libel in Cybercrime Law is. Like I read in the posts here in PDI that some senators are BOBO, walang alam, has damaged brain, copiador (putocoppier), political buttershefly, congressman eng-eng this ang-ang that, magnanakaw this, anak ng plunderer that, etc., etc. Oh, I might be bordering on libel here. Chow.

  • GMMTC11

    To be objective the law that they should have created is detailed to its lowest form to avoid any misinterpretation. It takes time, but thats the point that they have administrative services which the taxes are paying. It also means that they studied it properly,every possible scenarios, languages (as mentioned above), culture in the internet and anything else in the cyberspace. Hindi yong pwede na to pasok naman lahat. When a law is subject to various interpretation, it could also be a source of corruption later on as well as abuse of power.

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/RDDM5UQ45HLPPKM66KYEBCMTCE dave

    Gagawa gawa ka ng Law tapos hindi mo pala alam ang mga terms sa CYBERSPACE. Alam niyo po ang ang ibig sabihin ng “defaced website”, which will be taken down by DOJ, NBI or PNP without court order? Pinapagaralan niyo po ba ang ginagawa ninyo Senator bago niyo dinadraft ang inyong bill? Or gumagawa lang kayo base sa inyong sariling katwiran at narinig o nabasang terminolohiya?

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_3TWVIBNBHJIBKXLUC5IT2JYM5E Harry

    Trying to interpret his own law? That job belongs to the Supreme Court.

  • Christian Cabuay

    Makes sense that he’s an illiterate by today’s means. If you don’t understand technology today, you cannot function in a modern work environment. Just by using the term Cyber, shows how ignorant the lawmakers are. Nobody uses that term anymore. It’s so 1996. Let’s get these dinosaurs out of office. 



Copyright © 2013,
.
To subscribe to the Philippine Daily Inquirer newspaper in the Philippines, call +63 2 896-6000 for Metro Manila and Metro Cebu or email your subscription request here.
Factual errors? Contact the Philippine Daily Inquirer's day desk. Believe this article violates journalistic ethics? Contact the Inquirer's Reader's Advocate. Or write The Readers' Advocate:
c/o Philippine Daily Inquirer Chino Roces Avenue corner Yague and Mascardo Streets, Makati City, Metro Manila, Philippines Or fax nos. +63 2 8974793 to 94
Advertisement

News

  • Japanese, 80, is oldest to scale Everest
  • Estrada, old Cabinet discuss new job
  • Antipolo mayor files poll protest, accuses rival of fraud
  • Psst! It’s now PST, not ‘Filipino time’
  • Brillantes blames telcos anew for failure to transmit results
  • Sports

  • Lady Bulldogs’ poor reception key in V-League finals game one downfall, says coach
  • Lady Eagles seize Game 1 in 3
  • Azkals call off Kyrgyzstan friendly
  • Caluscusin top rhythmic gymnast with 3 golds
  • Big Chill rounds out D-League semis cast
  • Lifestyle

  • Beautiful, touching 30th-birthday bash for Cristalle Belo Henares
  • From swim goggles to SLRs
  • A learning tree on campus
  • #OOTD–the ‘outfit of the day’
  • Yellow chicken fast gaining popularity at Wee Nam Kee
  • Entertainment

  • Graphic gay sex stirs controversy at Cannes
  • New show will have ‘Party Pilipinas’ team
  • Bella Flores Foundation planned
  • A heady dose of indie rock, fashion at Wanderland fest
  • Kapatid wishes Willie well
  • Business

  • Tokyo plunges more than 7% as Asian markets fall
  • Coke workers’ strike ends in amicable settlement
  • Lenovo says quarterly profit up 90 percent
  • Switzerland eyes law on frozen dictator funds
  • Survey shows China manufacturing contracting
  • Technology

  • Media watchdog criticizes UAE over tweeter’s jail term
  • Twitter tightens security after high-profile breaches
  • Risky behavior starts young on web—survey
  • Office bullying video sparks outcry in Singapore
  • Poll: Teens migrating to Twitter
  • Opinion

  • Editorial cartoon, May 24, 2013
  • Out of the doldrums
  • Fighting over champagne
  • The poor didn’t benefit
  • Post-op
  • Global Nation

  • Pope Francis may visit Philippines in 2016—CBCP
  • Asia tension could lead to conflict—DFA chief
  • DOT seeks new markets for Boracay after Taiwan tourists cancel bookings
  • CA stops PH-Japanese contract to develop Nampeidai property in Tokyo
  • Brown hounded for calling Manila ‘gates of hell’
  • Marketplace
    Advertisement
    © Copyright 1997-2013 INQUIRER.net | All Rights Reserved